You may be receiving an error due to a saved cookie on your computer from your previous login information. Please click on this link which should remove any saved Classmates.com cookies while taking you to the login page, where you can enter your email address and your new password.
Please note also that if you previously saved your login information for Classmates in your browser such as Chrome or Firefox, you would need to go into that browser and either remove it completely or update it with your most recent password.